Ayurveda Treatment
Role of Yavasarshpadi churna dhupan (as antimicrobial and anti-fungal agent) In operation theater sterilization.
Introduction:
Dhupan karma is one of the classical ancient remedy of sterilization to maintain healthy biological environment all over the world. It is essential to maintain good asepsis to do various karmas. Kashyap Samhita have mentioned 40 dhupan yoga in dhup kalapadhyay; Sushrutacharya mentioned dhupan karma of Shalya karma mandir in Vranitopasaniya adhyay ,while Charakacharya mentioned dhupan of vastras and vranitagar in Jatasutriya sharir adhyay .
Dalhana explained procedure of sterilization in Sushrut Chikitsasthan. Before surgery Shalyakarma mandir must be fumigated or disinfected to avoid infections. The source of most hospital epidemics is infected patients i.e. patients contaminated with pathogenic organisms. These microorganisms are often released into environment in very high numbers, exceeding the minimal infective dose & contaminate others who subsequently develop hospital acquired infections. Yavasarshapadi churna dhup yog was used as antimicrobial and antifungal agent and its effect was compared with action of formalin gas fumigation on four specific groups of microorganisms which are highly responsible for creating fatal sepsis in operative theatres. Formalin gas fumigation has been proven to cause irritation to the mucus membrane affecting nose, eyes, lungs and can lead to asphyxia and carcinoma of the lungs. It is also responsible for abortions. So, Yavasarshapadi churna dhup yog2 herbomineral compound which is equally effective and can be used instead of formalin fumigation for operation theatre sterilization.
MATERIAL :
1. Yavasarshapadi dhoopa yoga
2. Two planned scale down models prepared by wooden box (size=2ft x 2 ft x1 ft) of 1/10th of the size of operation theatre no. 1 of our institute i.e.3200sq ft.
3. Specially designed Dhupan yantra
4. Yavasarshapadi churna =8gm
5. Goghrut = 8 gm
6. Formalin = 6ml
7. KMnO4 = 2 g
8. Species of staphylococcus aureus, Pseudomonas aeurigenosa, Ecoli, Candida albicans
9. Dry distillation apparatus.
10. T.L.C. Machine.
11. The aceutof GCV JMST100GCV machine.
12. Nutrient , mac conkey and SDA agar Culture medias’
Method of preparation of dhupa yog :
All the drugs were identified, standardised and authentified.
Following are the 14 constituent Dhupana yoga as mentioned by Charak-
Charak has not mentioned the exact amount of each drug to be taken so by using following reference of sharangadhar samhita,
Ingredients
|
Quantity
|
Yava churna
|
600mg.
|
Sarshapa churna
|
600mg.
|
Atasi churna
|
600mg.
|
Hingu churna
|
600mg.
|
Guggulu
|
600mg.
|
Vacha churna
|
600mg.
|
Choraka churna
|
600mg.
|
Bramhi churna
|
600mg.
|
Golomi churna
|
600mg.
|
Jatamansi churna
|
600mg.
|
Lakh churna
|
600mg.
|
Kutaki churna
|
600mg.
|
Sarpanirmok churna
|
600mg.
|
Ghrut
|
8gm.
|
1) Raw material needed to prepare Yavasarshapadi churna i.e. YavaSarshapa, Atasi, Hingu, Guggulu, Vacha, Choraka, Bramhi, Jatamansi, Laksha, Kutaki, Sarpanirmok, Ghrut were collected.
2) All the above substances were taken in equal amount.
3) Churnas were prepared. These churnas (powders) were mixed thoroughly with the help of mortal and pistal i.e.Khalva Yantra.
4) Above mixture of churnas was mixed together and Yava-sarshapadi choorna was prepared and stored in plastic containers kept at room temperature in dry place.
5) Amount of dravyas in dhupa yoga and duration of Dhupana karma was not mentioned in Samhita grantha.
Method of fumigation with both dhup yog and formalin gas:
6) With the reference mentioned in plant pathology; material taken in equal quantity of dhupana drvya with respect to combination of formalin (6ml) + KMnO4(2gm) for fumigation( fumigation quantity=2ml/cuft) to study their action comparatively.
7) Hence it was decided to give Dhupana to scale down model of Vranitagara with 8gm of Yava-sarshapadi churna with equal quantity of goghrut for 30 mins.(as whole Churna completely burnt out in 30 mins observed in pilot study) and chamber was kept remain closed for next 4 hours.
Efficacy of Yavasarshapadi dhupan yoga on given species of microorganisms was evaluated with 24 experimental cycles and an attempt was done to prove its action on these microorganisms with the help of thin layer chromatography along with gas chromatography and mass spectrometry.
Results and Discussion :
COMPARATIVE STATISTICAL STUDY OF TWO GROUP
A = DHUPAN B= GAS FUMIGATION
No.
|
Organisms
|
Group
|
Mean
|
S.D.
|
S.E.
|
t value
|
P value
|
Remark
| |
1
|
STAPHYLOCOCC
US AUREUS
|
A
|
B.T.
|
644.91
|
438.50
|
89.508
|
6.909
|
< 0.0001
|
Extremely Significant
|
A.T.
|
111.70
|
100.63
|
20.541
| ||||||
B
|
B.T.
|
644.91
|
438.50
|
89.508
|
5.736
|
< 0.0001
|
Extremely Significant
| ||
A.T.
|
273.04
|
23.04
|
41.44
| ||||||
2
|
PSEUDOMONAS AERUGINOSA
|
A
|
B.T.
|
825.125
|
421.42
|
86.022
|
8.80
|
< 0.0001
|
Extremely Significant
|
A.T.
|
174.58
|
131.13
|
26.76
| ||||||
B
|
B.T.
|
825.125
|
421.42
|
86.022
|
6.733
|
< 0.0001
|
Extremely Significant
| ||
A.T.
|
350.70
|
246.10
|
50.23
| ||||||
3
|
CANDIDA ALBICANS
|
A
|
B.T.
|
101.667
|
75.566
|
15.425
|
5.86
|
< 0.0001
|
Extremely Significant
|
A.T.
|
7.916
|
9.315
|
1.901
| ||||||
B
|
B.T.
|
101.667
|
75.566
|
15.425
|
4.689
|
< 0.0001
|
Extremely Significant
| ||
A.T.
|
28.166
|
19.016
|
3.882
| ||||||
4
|
E-COLI
|
A
|
B.T.
|
2083.083
|
1348.3
|
275.23
|
3.995
|
< 0.0001
|
Extremely Significant
|
A.T.
|
913.416
|
642.28
|
131.11
| ||||||
B
|
B.T.
|
2083.083
|
1348.3
|
275.23
|
2.666
|
< 0.0001
|
Significant
| ||
A.T.
|
1455.87
|
905.96
|
184.93
|
STATISTICAL ANALYSIS TABLE
1. Effect of Dhupan on STAPHYLOCOCCUS AUREUS
Mean
|
S.D.
|
S.E.
|
t value
|
P value
|
Remark
| |
B.T
|
644.91
|
438.50
|
89.508
|
6.909
|
< 0.0001
|
Extremely Significant
|
A.T.
|
111.70
|
100.63
|
20.541
|
Since P value is less than 0.0001, we reject Ho. Hence the Dhupan is significantly effective on this Staphyalococcus Aureus.
Effect of Fumigation on STAPHYLOCOCCUS AUREUS
Mean
|
S.D.
|
S.E.
|
t value
|
P value
|
Remark
| |
B.T
|
644.91
|
438.50
|
89.508
|
5.736
|
< 0.0001
|
Extremely Significant
|
A.T.
|
273.04
|
203.04
|
41.44
|
Since P value is less than 0.0001, we reject Ho. Hence Fumigation is significantly effective on this Staphylococcus Aureus.
2. Effect of Dhupan on PSEUDOMONAS AERUGINOSA
Mean
|
S.D.
|
S.E.
|
t value
|
P value
|
Remark
| |
B.T
|
825.125
|
421.42
|
86.022
|
8.80
|
< 0.0001
|
Extremely Significant
|
A.T.
|
174.58
|
131.13
|
26.76
|
Since P value is less than 0.0001, we reject Ho. Hence Dhupan is significantly effective on this Pseudomonas Aeruginosa.
Effect of Fumigation on PSEUDOMONAS AERUGINOSA
Mean
|
S.D.
|
S.E.
|
t value
|
P value
|
Remark
| |
B.T
|
825.125
|
421.42
|
86.022
|
6.733
|
< 0.0001
|
Extremely Significant
|
A.T.
|
350.70
|
246.10
|
50.23
|
Since P value is less than 0.0001, we reject Ho. Hence the Fumigation is significantly effective on this Pseudomonas Aeruginosa.
3. Effect of Dhupan on CANDIDA ALBICANS
Mean
|
S.D.
|
S.E.
|
t value
|
P value
|
Remark
| |
B.T
|
101.667
|
75.566
|
15.425
|
5.86
|
< 0.0001
|
Extremely Significant
|
A.T.
|
7.916
|
9.315
|
1.901
|
Since P value is less than 0.0001, we reject Ho. Hence, Dhupan is significantly effective on Candida Albicans.
Effect of Fumigation on CANDIDA ALBICANS
Mean
|
S.D.
|
S.E.
|
t value
|
P value
|
Remark
| |
B.T
|
101.667
|
75.566
|
15.425
|
4.689
|
< 0.0001
|
Extremely Significant
|
A.T.
|
28.166
|
19.016
|
3.882
|
Since P value is less than 0.0001, we reject Ho. Hence, Dhupan is significantly effective on Candida Albicans.
4. Effect of Dhupan on E-Coli
Mean
|
S.D.
|
S.E.
|
t value
|
P value
|
Remark
| |
B.T
|
2083.083
|
1348.3
|
275.23
|
3.995
|
< 0.0001
|
Extremely Significant
|
A.T.
|
913.416
|
642.28
|
131.11
|
Since P value is less than 0.0001, we reject Ho. Hence,Dhupan is significantly effective on E-Coli.
Effect of Fumigation on E-Coli
Mean
|
S.D.
|
S.E.
|
t value
|
P value
|
Remark
| |
B.T
|
2083.083
|
1348.3
|
275.23
|
2.666
|
< 0.0001
|
Significant
|
A.T.
|
1455.87
|
905.96
|
184.93
|
Since P value is less than 0.0001, we reject Ho. Hence, Fumigation is significantly effective on E-Coli.
From the above results growth of microorganisms of staphylococcus aureus, pseudomonas aeruginosa, Candida albicans was found to be extremely significant in both the groups while in case of E coli, result observed after dhupan was found to be extremely significant as compared to formalin gas fumigation.
In this study, the trial was conducted on four species of microorganisms staphylococcus aureus, pseudomonas aeruginosa, candida albicans & Ecoli; divided in two groups. The microorganisms were selected for 24 experimental cycles. Their colony count was done before and after dhupan and fumigation. Yavasarshapadi churna dhupa yoga was found to be equally effective as compared to formalin gas fumigation. Yava-sarshapadi Dhupan yoga for the fumigation of scale down model of Vranitagara was selected for the present study by considering its significance mentioned in Ayurvedic texts. Dhupana should be done for Arishtagara Vastra, Shayya, Asanadi of Bala to avoid Neonatal sepsis.3
Effectivity of dhupana:It has been observed from the results derived from all 24 cycles of experiments that action of dhupan yoga was approximately similar to that of formalin gas fumigation in case of 3 species i.e. staphylococcus aureus, pseudomonas aeruginosa and candida albicans. But amongst these experiments i found thatdhupan yoga showed marked effect on growth of e coli as compared to formalin gas fumigation. Hence, considering all the parameters it was proved that Yavasarshapadi churnadhupa yoga was efficient to reduce the growth of 4 species of microorganisms i.e.staphylococcus aureus, pseudomonas aeruginosa, Ecoli and candida albicans on planned scale down model of the vranitagara.
Probable mode of action of Yavasarshapadi churna Dhupa Yoga:
The mode of action of Yavasarshapadi dhupa yoga was probably due to Agni sanmskar on dhupa dravya were used for dhupan karma. Dhupa dravya has Vayu, Akash andAgni Mahabhootadhikya. Sukshmastrotogamitva attained owing to the combination of these mahabhootas. So, the sterilization property of drugs is maintained in every corners and at microbiological level.1
Action of indigenous drugs :
Yava, sarshapa, Atasi, Hingu, Guggulu,Vacha,Choraka,Bramhi, kutaki are mentioned to be krumighna in Samitas and Nighantus. Ghrut is essential for combustion of all the constituents.Sarpanirmok is mentioned in Kashyap Samhita Dhupakalpa Adhyaya four times as Rakshoghna.Laksa is also mentioned in Kashyap Samhita in twoDhupa kalpas as Rakshogna karma. 3,5,6
Action of drug in accordance to modern perspective:
26 volatile constituents were found after Gas chromatography and mass spectrometry study and some of them found to have microbiocidal and fugicidal action over the four species which i had taken under the study.
I referred literature of individual constituents, some of them were appeared to be presented in a raw material of my herbs and they were likely to come in the atmosphere when separated during dhupan process.
Out of 26 volatile constituents some of them were found to be present in the drugs of my dhupan yoga which are listed below,
Decyl, trifluoracetate has fungicidal and microbiocidal action. Dodecane which was found to be present in a drugs belonging to family vulgare from which yava belongs, likely to have fungicidal and antimicrobial activity.Hexacosyl trichloroacetate has antimicrobial action.Hepatocosyl trifluoroacetate which is effective against candida albicans, e coli, psalmonella species.Oxirane (oxacyclopropanes), 2 butyl,3 methyl cis and pthalic acids (pthalides) found in choraka proven as a good fungicide and bactericide.Phenol, 2,4 bis (1,1 dimethylethyl) found in kutaki also has the same action.Pentanoic acid is a good antimicrobial and antifungal agent.Hexadecane , nonadecane, hexadecanoic acid, methyl ester, Pentadecanoic acid and octadecanoic acid most likely found in drugs belong to the family vulgare.3 chlorpropionic acid is most likely found in shweta durva. Mustard oil is potent mutagenic, so it might act as genetic modulator in microbes.So no such study has been conducted and it is further scope of research.Linseed oil have antimicrobial activity obtained from seeds of Atasi. Volatile oil from roots of Vacha inhibited the growth of Mycobacterium tuberculosis in a concentration of 10 mcg/ml. Ethanolic extract of Bacopa monnieri antibacterial activity seen in more effective in Gram –ve bacteria.The aqueous extract of bramhi showed moderate antibacterial activity against Staph. Aureus and Salmonela typhi, and marked inhibition against Esch.Coli. Volatile oils from roots of Acorus calamus Linn. inhibited the growth of gram-vegative organisms.Volatile oils from gum-resin of Guggulu shows antibacterial activity.The aqueous extract showed moderate antibacterial activity against Staph. Aureus and Salmonela typhi, and marked inhibition against Esch. Coli.
Conclusion:
One of the mechanisms of action was explored in the current study to find out volatile constituents in the atmosphere which were responsible for antimicrobial and antifungal action on the microorganisms.
No comments:
Post a Comment